Home  /  Disputes

Make-good disputes on the Sunshine Coast

Why they happen, what the Queensland process is, and how a written scope and a contractor's quote turn an argument into a number.

Why disputes happen

The Queensland Small Business Commissioner lists the causes, and they are consistent: no evidence of the premises' condition at the start, a vague clause, disagreement about the quality of the make good, and argument over whether something the tenant added has value the landlord should keep. Almost every one of them comes back to something that was not written down.

Nobody disputes a photograph. They dispute a memory.

The Queensland process

  1. Direct negotiation. Tenant and landlord, in writing, with the lease, the condition report and the photographs on the table. Most disputes resolve here if both parties have documents.
  2. Mediation through the Queensland Small Business Commissioner. A free or low-cost mediation service for commercial lease disputes. Either party can apply. The Commissioner can mediate disputes up to a substantial value threshold.
  3. QCAT. For retail shop leases, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal hears disputes that mediation does not resolve. Non-retail commercial leases may go to court instead.

Each step costs more time and money than the last, and each is easier with a written record than without.

Clipboard with a printed condition report and a tablet showing photographs on a windowsill in an empty office
The evidence. A dispute with this is a conversation. A dispute without it is a fight

Where a contractor's quote fits

Most make-good disputes come down to money: the landlord says the work will cost X, the tenant thinks it is Y. An itemised quote from a contractor who has seen the tenancy and the lease clause is the number that grounds the conversation. It shows what the obligation actually costs, line by line, and it exposes items that are beyond the lease or that are wear and tear.

Landlords use quotes the same way when recharging a tenant who left without doing the work. Two quotes, one from each side, usually land within negotiating distance of each other.

Common dispute items and how they resolve

  • Fair wear and tear versus damage. Faded paint and worn carpet are wear. Fixing holes and cut ceiling tiles are damage. Photographs from lease start settle it.
  • Standard of repairs. Patch painting versus full walls. The lease standard and the base building specification decide.
  • Items the landlord wants kept. If the landlord wants the fitout for the next tenant, the make good should be reduced accordingly, in writing.
  • Base building versus tenant fitout. What was there at the start is the landlord's. The condition report defines it.
  • Cost of works. Competing quotes, compared line by line.

Practical steps if a dispute starts

  1. Stop communicating verbally. Everything in writing.
  2. Get the landlord's position itemised: what they say is outstanding and what they say it costs.
  3. Assemble the lease, the condition report, your photographs and your contractor's quote.
  4. Respond item by item, with evidence.
  5. Propose a resolution: complete specific items, or a cash figure.
  6. If no movement, apply for mediation.
  7. Get legal advice before anything escalates further.
Written September 2026

Get advice before you rely on this

This page describes the Queensland make-good dispute process in general terms as at September 2026. Processes and thresholds change.

The Queensland Small Business Commissioner offers mediation on commercial and retail lease disputes and publishes guidance on make good and bond return. Retail lease disputes may proceed to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. Statutory provisions are in the Property Law Act 2023 and the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 at legislation.qld.gov.au. Where anything here differs from those sources, they are right and we are not.

We are not lawyers or mediators. A make-good dispute is a legal matter. Get advice early, before positions harden.

Accurate at the time of writing, September 2026. Always check the source before relying on it.

Questions

Common questions

What causes most make-good disputes?

No condition report from lease start, a vague clause, disagreement about repair quality, and argument over items the landlord wants kept. Nearly all of them come back to something not written down.

Where do I go to resolve one?

Direct negotiation in writing first. Then mediation through the Queensland Small Business Commissioner. Then QCAT for retail leases, or court for other commercial leases.

Is mediation free?

The Small Business Commissioner's mediation service is low-cost or free, depending on the dispute. It is designed to be accessible to small businesses.

How does a contractor's quote help?

It turns the dispute into a number. An itemised quote to the lease clause shows what the obligation actually costs and exposes items that are beyond the lease or are wear and tear.

The landlord wants to keep our fitout but also charge us for removal. Can they?

Not both. If the landlord keeps the fitout for the next tenant, the make good is reduced accordingly. Get the agreement in writing.

What is the difference between wear and tear and damage?

Wear is normal ageing: faded paint, worn carpet. Damage is from the fitout: fixing holes, cut tiles, penetrations. Only damage is the tenant's to fix. Photos from lease start settle it.

Should I get a lawyer?

Before it escalates past direct negotiation, yes. A make-good dispute is a legal matter about a lease, and early advice is cheaper than late advice.

Can the landlord recharge me for doing the work themselves?

If the tenant fails to meet the obligation, the landlord can generally do the work and recover the cost, often from the bond. That is why doing it properly beforehand is cheaper.

Next step

Send the tenancy and the date

Address, rough size, what is in there, and when the lease ends. That is usually enough for a price without anyone visiting.

Scroll to Top